The Port Byron Family Tree – 4; The Buck family

Updated- Although the village of Port Byron was once called Bucksville, I had not done a lot of genealogy on the Buck family as many in the family they had moved to Illinois around 1831. So I have not paid them too much attention, just because I have other families to chase. Well, a couple weeks ago my wife and I were in Chemung, NY, for a canal society field trip, and the local historian was talking about Buck’s Point along the Chemung River. I recalled that our Bucksville Buck’s were from that area, and that made me think that I should add them to the PBFT. But how?

To help search them out and develop a nice timeline, there are some very good histories written about the Buck family, which you can find on Google Books. And the blog Historical Echoes of Chemung, NY , has a post about the Buck Family.

So this is the background. Phillip King moved to the area around 1795 and soon after others followed. These included the brothers Aholiab and Elijah Buck, who came here from Pennsylvania (near Chemung). The Buck brothers were very forward thinking and gave land away to anyone who wished to set up a mill or store, as they wanted to see the settlement grow. So by the time the canal was built through the small hamlet in 1819, the area had become known as Bucksville. However, as the hamlet grew toward becoming a village, some wished to see the name changed and in 1825 the name was changed to Port Byron. This post covers that name change.

My suspicion is that Aholiab was upset over this name change and moved west. A Buck researcher told me about The Portrait and Biographical Album of Otoe and Cass Counties, Nebraske (page 936) which states that Aholiab moved as he lost his land through, “the dishonestly of others.” A deed I have shows that Buck sold his land to John Beach for $5,000, which would have been a lot of money. But anyhow, Aholiab moved his family to Illinois by 1831, while brother Elijah stayed here.

Elijah married Theresa Drake and together they gave birth to Daniel D Buck (the D was for Drake). Daniel married Julia Ann Eaman or Emmons. The 1850 census shows an Elizabeth Emmons living with the family, but the Buck researcher says it should be Eaman. Daniel and Julia Ann had Elijah. Elijah married Lucy Tuell, and they had two daughters, who both moved to Oswego. The last of two, Cora, died in the 1940’s, and that was the end of the Buck line in Port Byron. I will note that all the family records show that Aholiab also married a Drake by the name of Annis. The mother of the Drake girls was Abigail Anna Knapp, so there deserves to be more investigation there as Knapp is also a local name. And interestingly, the Biographical Album notes that the Drake family was a descendant of the Prince of Orange and they were one of the first settlers of Manhattan Island.

But how to wrap the Buck family into the PBFT? Nelson Buck, who was one of Aholiab’s sons. His first wife was Fidelia Wethey, a young lady who died in 1833. Penny Heltzer and Find a Grave say that this couple had a son named Oliver. However, most Wethey trees show the family coming from this union as being the Wethey’s, not the Buck’s. So is this an error? Perhaps the Wethey family took in Oliver and raised him after Nelson left town?

But, thanks to Fidelia, the we can tie the Buck family into the PBFT!

2 thoughts on “The Port Byron Family Tree – 4; The Buck family

  1. Correction Daniel Drake Buck married the daughter of Jacob and Elizabeth Eaman, Source Jacob and Elizabeth Eaman’s Probate records. Box 13-58 and box 22-57. Daniel Buck was also a Sheriff of Cayuga County.
    There is a nice write up about the Buck family in 1789. History of Cayuga County, New York by Elliot G. Storke assisted by Jas. H. Smith pages 311 & 313
    In Biographical Album of Otoe and Cass Counties (Nebraska) available online google books pages 935-936 John F Buck born in 1815 he gives his birth place as Metz township, Cayuga Co., N.Y. On page 936 is an account of why Aholiab Buck left Port Byron in 1831. Another Biographical Record is written for Nelson Buck, titled, The Biographical Record of Livingston and Woodford Counties, Illinois, 1900 pages 205-205. The book calls attention to his first wife Miss Fidelia Withey but does not mention a son. Also, a short paragraph about the Buck family of New York Nelson Buck was born in New York April 10, 1808.
    Another source I found helpful was the Port Byron Library has a folder on the Buck family.
    I am a Buck/Drake/ Eaman New York descendent. Abigail Buck daughter of Aholiab married Jacob Eaman Jr.

    1. Thanks for the reply. In the 1850 census, it shows Elizabeth Emmons, which could be a mistake from Eaman, and as many trees on Ancestry were using Emms, I took the more logical choice. I will note this correction. And I will search for the Buck history as you suggest. Penny Heltzer mentions the birth of Oliver to Nelson and Fidelia, as does the Find a Grave site. Both could be in error, however it would make sense for Fidelia to have died in childbirth, and for the Wethey family to take in the child and raise him as their own. I got to visit the Buck cemetery in Chemung this week. Hope you have been there.

Comments are closed.